What US News · A look at the worldNews · Analysis · History · A different approach
Articles

Senate backs Trump and rejects limits on his Iran war powers

Ala del Senado del Capitolio de Estados Unidos
Foto: U.S. Capitol / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The U.S. Senate on Thursday, November 19, rejected a resolution that sought to force President Donald Trump to withdraw the armed forces from the conflict with Iran. The vote was 48 to 51, and the Republican majority stood firmly behind the commander in chief.

It was the first time either chamber had voted on the war since the November 3 midterm elections. Democrats hoped the election results would give them the votes they had lacked in earlier attempts. They did not get them.

How the vote went

The resolution had already been approved by the House of Representatives. In the Senate, only three Republicans supported it: Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky. On the other side, Democrat John Fetterman of Pennsylvania broke with his party and voted against it.

  • Result: 48 votes in favor and 51 against.
  • Three Republicans voted in favor: Collins, Murkowski and Paul.
  • One Democrat voted against: John Fetterman.
  • Republican Thom Tillis, who backed an earlier attempt, voted against it this time.
  • Since the war began in late February, Democrats have forced more than a dozen votes of this kind. Nearly all have failed.

A measure with more noise than effect

The text directed the president “to remove United States Armed Forces from hostilities with Iran.” However, its effect would have been largely symbolic. It was a concurrent resolution, which does not go to the president’s desk. In addition, administrations of both parties have argued that this mechanism of the 1973 War Powers Resolution is unconstitutional, and the White House already rejected its validity when a similar measure passed over the summer.

Tillis himself explained it to CBS News: “This one doesn’t go to the president, so it’s just a statement from Congress. I’ve made that statement.”

What Democrats say

Democratic Sen. Tim Kaine of Virginia, who has led these efforts, urged Republicans to change their votes. According to Kaine, the election results showed that the war is unpopular and that voters are worried about its cost to the economy.

But the Senate majority saw it differently: tying the president’s hands in the middle of an active conflict would send a signal of weakness to Tehran. All the more so as Iran keeps attacking tankers and Gulf countries, and as U.S. intelligence has detected Iranian plans against officials in Washington.

Conclusion

The Senate’s message is clear: Iran policy is directed by the president. After weeks of pressure and a tough election for Republicans, the majority did not let itself be dragged along by political calculation. In the middle of a war, the United States needs a single command and a single voice in front of the ayatollahs’ regime, and on Thursday the Senate gave Trump that backing.

God bless America.

Sources

📱 Get the What US News app

QR code for the What US News app

Scan the code with your phone or go to whatusnews.com/app. Free for Android and iPhone. How to install it.

About the author

Aliesky Rodriguez

See all articles by this author →

Conversation

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep reading

Español Get the app