The Trump administration took a step this week that the left is already calling cruel, but that many taxpayers see as pure common sense. The Department of Agriculture (USDA) published on November 10 in the Federal Register a proposal to reform the so-called “categorical eligibility” of SNAP, the food stamp program. The idea is simple: that the aid reach those who truly meet the requirements Congress set.
What “categorical eligibility” is
The law allows households that receive assistance from TANF, the cash aid program for needy families, to enter SNAP automatically. Over the years, many states stretched that rule with what is called broad-based categorical eligibility (BBCE). Receiving a minor benefit paid for with TANF funds, such as an informational brochure or a referral to a help line, was enough to skip the normal income and asset limits.
The result was a patchwork of different rules in each state. In some, incomes well above the federal limit were accepted, and in others nobody looked at how much money the family had saved or how many assets it had.
What changes with the proposal
According to the text published by the USDA, automatic eligibility would remain only for households that truly receive TANF assistance. Everyone else would go back to the rules Congress approved.
- Gross income: up to 130% of the federal poverty line.
- Net income: up to 100% of that line. Households with elderly or disabled members only have to meet this limit.
- Assets: the federal resource limits would apply again.
- Impact: about 6.3 million people, in 3.2 million households, would no longer be eligible in fiscal year 2029.
- Savings: about $44.6 billion in federal benefits between 2027 and 2031.
- Public comments: open until December 10, 2026.
Millionaires on food stamps
The USDA explains that these policies went beyond what Congress intended, which was only to simplify the program’s administration. The document mentions cases of millionaires who received SNAP in states with no asset limit, and reports from the Government Accountability Office (GAO) and the inspector general that point to more payment errors among households that came in by this route.
It is not a new idea. In 2019, during his first term, Trump already proposed a similar reform, but it was never finalized and the Biden administration scrapped it. Today SNAP serves more than 40 million Americans, and every misspent dollar is a dollar that comes out of the pockets of working families who pay taxes.
The criticism
Groups that defend the program warn that the measure will mostly affect low-income workers. Gina Plata-Nino, of the Food Research & Action Center (FRAC), warned, according to The New York Times, that the hardest hit would be the working poor. States and organizations that wish to can send their comments before the USDA approves the final version. It is a concern that deserves respect. But the answer cannot be to keep a system in which a brochure opens the door to benefits meant for the neediest.
Conclusion
Food assistance is a safety net for those going through a hard time, not a blank check. Going back to the rules Congress wrote protects those who truly need SNAP and respects those who pay for it with their work. That is the difference between a government that manages responsibly and one that only hands things out. God bless America.
Sources
- Federal Register: SNAP, reforming categorical eligibility
- The New York Times: the proposal to restrict SNAP eligibility
- Agri-Pulse: the USDA’s similar proposal in 2019
📱 Get the What US News app

Scan the code with your phone or go to whatusnews.com/app. Free for Android and iPhone. How to install it.






Conversation